Tourism is a crucial pillar of global economic development, attracting millions of visitors annually, driving business growth, and creating jobs worldwide. However, it is also associated with significant environmental and social challenges, especially in climate change and sustainability. The tourism industry is increasingly recognising the need to integrate sustainable practices into its operations, and one critical tool in this endeavour is the Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD) framework.
Established by the Financial Stability Board in 2015, the TCFD framework encourages organisations to report on governance, strategy, risk management, and metrics related to climate change. While initially intended for financial institutions, the TCFD framework has gained traction across various industries, including tourism.
Benefits from TCFD adoption in the tourism sector.
It helps companies assess and disclose climate-related risks such as extreme weather events, sea-level rise, and changes in tourist behaviour. This information can help businesses develop robust strategies to mitigate risks, improve resilience, and adapt to changing environmental conditions.
Moreover, TCFD reporting can enhance investor confidence and facilitate access to capital for sustainable tourism projects and initiatives. Transparency in disclosing sustainability performance, including climate-related risks and opportunities, gives investors a clearer picture of a company’s commitment to sustainable practices.
The TCFD framework also fosters stakeholder engagement and strengthens the reputation of tourism businesses. A standardised communication and accountability framework encourages stakeholder collaboration, including local communities, governments, and non-governmental organisations. This engagement fosters trust, strengthens reputation, and enhances the industry’s social license to operate.
TCFD Benefits in the long-run.
Regarding long-term sustainability planning, TCFD reporting prompts tourism organisations to develop strategies that align with climate goals. By identifying and addressing climate risks, businesses can proactively plan for a low-carbon future, reducing their environmental impact and ensuring the industry’s long-term viability.
However, implementing TCFD reporting in the tourism sector is challenging. The availability and standardisation of relevant data is a significant issue. Companies, tiny and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs), must invest in data collection systems and methodologies to ensure accurate reporting. Industry collaboration and the development of industry-specific metrics can help address this challenge.
Collaboration and knowledge sharing are also crucial for fully leveraging the potential of TCFD reporting. Tourism organisations can learn from best practices, engage in industry partnerships, and participate in sustainability networks to enhance their reporting capabilities and share insights. Governments, industry associations, and NGOs can play a vital role in facilitating these collaborations.
Technology influence on TCFD Reporting
Technological advancements and innovation can also support TCFD reporting in the tourism sector. Blockchain, artificial intelligence, and big data analytics can improve data collection, verification, and reporting processes. Moreover, innovative solutions can drive sustainable practices within the industry, such as intelligent destination management systems, renewable energy adoption, and waste reduction strategies.
The TCFD framework is valuable in promoting transparency and driving sustainable practices in the tourism industry. Despite challenges, adopting TCFD reporting enables tourism businesses to mitigate risks, attract investment, strengthen their reputation, and contribute to a resilient and environmentally sustainable industry. In a rapidly changing global landscape, aligning with the TCFD framework can help ensure the long-term viability of the tourism sector.
Current joint efforts in Travel & Tourism, such as Tourism Declares a Climate Emergency and the Glasgow Declaration on Climate Action for Tourism, underscore the industry’s commitment to sustainable practices. Furthermore, the involvement of various travel and tourism businesses in initiatives like the SBTi and Race to Zero further emphasises this commitment.
Possible Business Models for Tourism during the Race to Zero.
Tourism encompasses various business models, carbon emission profiles, and decarbonisation pathways. These include accommodation providers, from multinational hotel groups to small businesses with a single property; tour operators, who create package tours by combining different travel components; airlines; cruise ships; and tourism intermediaries such as online travel agencies, travel agencies, and metasearch engines. Each industry presents unique challenges and opportunities for implementing TCFD reporting and promoting sustainable practices.
Shared challenges across these industries include emission measurement and reporting, regulatory frameworks and government support, financing, and infrastructure dependency. Emission measurement is particularly challenging for Scope 3 emissions, including all indirect emissions in a company’s value chain. Regulatory uncertainties and lack of government support add to the complexities of planning for and implementing sustainable practices.
In the face of insufficient regulatory incentives and frameworks, businesses in the sector often need help prioritising their internal budget and financing to support investments required for achieving net-zero emissions. Moreover, dependence on local infrastructure can significantly affect travel and tourism businesses, as their ability to decarbonise is often limited by local energy and waste infrastructures, transportation options, sustainability performance of available buildings, port facilities, and so on.
Despite these challenges, the potential benefits of adopting TCFD reporting in the tourism sector are significant. Through collaboration, knowledge sharing, technological innovation, and industry-specific adaptations of the TCFD framework, businesses can overcome these obstacles and move towards a more sustainable future.
Adopting TCFD reporting by the tourism industry is crucial in addressing the climate crisis and promoting sustainable tourism practices. It enables businesses to assess and manage climate-related risks, attract investment in sustainable projects, and engage with stakeholders transparently and accountable. Furthermore, it supports long-term sustainability planning and helps ensure the industry’s viability in a rapidly changing global landscape.
Reporting in the tourism sector: potential criticisms and limitations.
- Complexity and Cost: Implementing TCFD recommendations involves significant sophistication and potentially high costs. For smaller businesses in the tourism sector, such as small tour operators or local hotels, the resources required for detailed climate risk assessments and scenario analyses may be prohibitive.
- Lack of Data: The tourism sector is highly diverse, making it challenging to aggregate data and compare different types of businesses. Moreover, there may be limited availability of relevant climate-related data, making it difficult for companies to make accurate assessments and disclosures.
- Inadequate Expertise: TCFD reporting requires particular expertise in climate science, financial modelling, and risk management. Many businesses in the tourism sector may need more expertise in this area.
- Unclear Materiality: The materiality of climate risks for businesses in the tourism sector can be uncertain and will vary greatly depending on the context. For example, a ski resort may face significant physical risks due to warming temperatures, whereas a city hotel may face more transitional risks related to changing regulations or customer preferences.
- Difficulties in Scenario Analysis: The TCFD recommends using scenario analysis to understand future climate-related risks and opportunities. However, the long time horizons and uncertainties associated with climate change make it particularly challenging for businesses in the tourism sector to conduct meaningful scenario analyses.
- Voluntary Nature: TCFD reporting is voluntary, which can lead to inconsistent reporting levels and potentially allow businesses to omit less favourable information. That can limit the usefulness of TCFD disclosures for investors and other stakeholders.
In conclusion, TCFD reporting, despite its challenges, presents a significant opportunity for the tourism industry to contribute to global sustainability goals and ensure its long-term resilience. By integrating this framework into their operations, tourism businesses can enhance their competitiveness, strengthen their reputation, and contribute to a resilient and environmentally sustainable industry.
Recent articles that might also interest you:
Climate Action Now: TCFD and Fashion Industry’s Impact